Search

Displaying 91 - 105 of 236

Lesson
The TCR could also have augmented its analysis in addition to listing the titles of the consultants’ reports. For a policy and advisory TA with the target of developing policy analysis for government agencies’ reference and consideration the TA’s findings and policy recommendations should offer inspiring perspectives and insights that are addition to what, in the absence of the TA, would have been available to and well known by the targeted audience. To this end, the TCR should have adequately discussed the reports’ contents and quality.

Project Number: 48460-001
Project Name: Promoting the Decisive Role of Market in Resource Allocation
Report Date:
Lesson
As the TCR stated, other factors (often political) play an important role and are beyond the control of a TA project. Therefore, a broader lesson learned could be: Clearly aligning the intended outcome with its indicators and TA project’s outputs is critical for avoiding any attribution issues. In this TA project, the intended outcome was dependent on many other external factors over which the TA project had no control.

Project Number: 48459-001
Project Name: Reforms in the Public Sector Compensation System
Report Date:
Lesson
A lesson could be identified here: The outcome indicator(s) of a policy and advisory TA shall be deliberately designed to establish a reasonable cause–effect relationship between outputs and outcome, and, therefore,ensure a logical appropriateness and continuum of the DMF results chain. It isimportant that the outcome indicator(s) reflect the immediate and direct benefits of application of TA outputs, rather than aim to address a high-level development issue, which would bedisproportionately ambitious and complex for a TA.

Project Number: 48460-001
Project Name: Promoting the Decisive Role of Market in Resource Allocation
Report Date:
Lesson
Agree. However, such alignment was a necessary, but insufficient prerequisite to developing relevant and useful knowledge products and policy recommendations. The TCR could have more thoroughly discussed the TA design, with particular attention to the DMF results chain (refer to Relevance section for details). It could also have further discussed on the unattained ambitious outcome performance indicators from the perspective of DMF design.

Project Number: 48460-001
Project Name: Promoting the Decisive Role of Market in Resource Allocation
Report Date:
Lesson
There is a need for careful planning in the context of an exploratory TA, such as this one, to allow for timely delivery of outputs while ensuring process and cost efficiency

Project Number: 47146-001
Project Name: Macroeconomic Modelling for Improved Economic Assessment
Report Date:
Lesson
For regional assistance involving multiple partners, a longer-term, flexible, and programmatic approach can be an effective operational modality to meet development partners' requirements and developing member countries' demands in an evolving policy and regulatory context.

Project Number: 46500-001
Project Name: Establishment of the Pacific Regional Infrastructure Facility Coordination Office
Report Date:
Lesson
This is a valid lesson. In addition, when extending or amending a TA, clear articulation of changes in expected outcomes should be provided.

Project Number: 46374-001
Project Name: Southern Highways Investment Program
Report Date:
Lesson
The validation agrees with the lesson that alignment of TA project design with ADB operational priorities and workplans can help ensure smoother implementation, monitoring, and reporting.

Project Number: 48206-001
Project Name: Promoting Gender Equality and Women's Empowerment (Phase 2)
Report Date:
Lesson
Well-phrased as a lesson, assuming the lack of training was the main underlying issue. Given that audit observations presumably came in annually, there could have been time to adjust the TA project activities to address the identified issue. However, it is unclear from the TCR whether factors other than inadequate training contributed to the issue.

Project Number: 45317-001
Project Name: Support for the Third Primary Education Development Project
Report Date:
Lesson
The DMF must include outcomes for each of the output areas, given the diverse and significant nature of the outputs and their contribution to Mongolia’s financial stability. The DMF included outcomes for three of the five output areas, making it difficult to track the TA project’s contributions.

Project Number: 50017-001
Project Name: Supporting Financial Sector Development and Stability
Report Date:
Lesson
This validation also adds that choosing and defining outcome indicators that can be directly attributed to TA outputs can improve a program’s relevanc and effectiveness.

Project Number: 45396-001
Project Name: Enhancing the Regulatory Framework of Financial Sector Development and Oversight
Report Date:
Lesson
Consultations with the government and development partners are critical for ensuring that the government has sufficient implementation capacity, increasing synergies and reducing duplication. In this TA project, ADB did not sufficiently consult with the government with regard to e-licensing, which resulted in delays due to the lack of capacity on XBRL in OJK’s IT department. ADB also did not sufficiently consult with the World Bank, which resulted in several activities being part of the TA design that the government had already agreed on being financed by the World Bank.

Project Number: 45396-001
Project Name: Enhancing the Regulatory Framework of Financial Sector Development and Oversight
Report Date:
Lesson
This is a useful lesson learned, but it is phrased as a recommendation. Rephrasing it into a lesson learned: Engaging with stakeholders extensively (including those that may not be directly involved in the TA project) while designing the TA can increase ownership of its activities among national stakeholders and support a timely implementation of TA activities. This TA project would have benefited from focus group discussions with stakeholders in the banking and capital market sector. Topics could have included financial inclusion, financial literacy, and consumer protection.

Project Number: 45396-001
Project Name: Enhancing the Regulatory Framework of Financial Sector Development and Oversight
Report Date:
Lesson
Agreed. The inclusion of assessment of current operational capacity is integral to the formulation of a framework for infrastructure development.

Project Number: 45078-001
Project Name: Strategic Masterplan for Chittagong Port
Report Date:
Lesson
In addition to the lessons identified in the TCR, an additional lesson would be: Allowing flexibility to expand the scope and modify planned activities is beneficial for achieving the desired outcome. In this TA, the additional funding through the Republic of Korea e_x005F_x0002_Asia and Knowledge Partnership Fund supported the identification of policy reform actions for the regulatory environment governing local health care delivery to ease forward implementation.

Project Number: 50285-001
Project Name: Support to Strengthening Local Health Care Program
Report Date: